Nuclear and Atomic Physics

   

Comment on "Analyses of Mössbauer Experiments in a Rotating System: Proper and Improper Approaches"

Authors: Jaykov Foukzon

In paper [1] published recently A. L.Kholmetskii et al.argued that S.A.Podosenov et al. paper [2] wrong and cannot explain nowel Mössbauer experiment in a rotating system. However paper [1] contains a lot of principal mistakes: (i) first notice that [1] based on rejection the Einstein equivalence principle (EEP) (see [3]) and misconception in basic notion of GRT. By using these misconception A. L.Kholmetskii et al.argued that: "the problem of the physical interpretation of the observed energy shift between emission and absorption lines in a rotating system under the framework of general relativity open". Ofcourse after rejection the EEP under the framework of general relativity one explains nothing. (ii) secondary note that paper [1] based on misleading in quantum optics. In quantum optics we dealing with the probability density w(t,r),r∈ℝ³ such that w(t,‖r‖,Ω)δΩdt is the probability of the photon registration near point r, between instant t and t+dt by a detector with angular size δΩ≪1sr and located at the point r∈ℝ³.The probability density w(t,r) is not highly localized in free space except unphysical 1D case known from literature (see [4],5B 1.2).A single photons cannot be localized by using photodetector. Nevertheless in order to disprove S.A.Podosenov et al. paper [2], A. L.Kholmetskii et al. in [1] naively argued that γ-quanta is a point particle and propagate along highly localized classical trajectory. But this is a missconcept. Remark 1. But more importantly, these authors deliberately mislead readers by reporting absolutely false information about the experimental results stated in the classical papers [5]-[9]. A. L.Kholmetskii et al. wrote (see [1] p.5): However, "it becomes obvious that Podosenov et al. [26] did not even realize the fact that Eq. (11) indicates a red shift of the frequency of the resonant radiation (i.e., ν_{R}<ν₀ ), whereas the equality k=2/3 in Eq. (4), obtained in the experiments [9--12] corresponds to the blue shift of the resonant radiation when ν_{R}>ν₀. We add that the same blue shift of the frequency of the resonant γ -quanta has been obtained in all other Mössbauer rotor experiments [1--6] (see corresponding ref.[5]-[9] in this paper) in the configuration where the source of resonant radiation was located on the rotational axis, and the resonant absorber was mounted on the rotor rim". Remark 1. Note that in classical Mössbauer rotor experiments [1]--[6] only a red shift in full accordance with GRT prediction without any doubt were obtained. [Truncated by viXra Admin to <400 words]

Comments: 26 Pages. Accepted by Journal of High Energy Physics, Gravitation and Cosmology [Corrections made by viXra Admin to confirm with the requirements on the Replacement Form]

Download: PDF

Submission history

[v1] 2020-12-17 11:23:07
[v2] 2021-01-24 18:30:31

Unique-IP document downloads: 283 times

Vixra.org is a pre-print repository rather than a journal. Articles hosted may not yet have been verified by peer-review and should be treated as preliminary. In particular, anything that appears to include financial or legal advice or proposed medical treatments should be treated with due caution. Vixra.org will not be responsible for any consequences of actions that result from any form of use of any documents on this website.

Add your own feedback and questions here:
You are equally welcome to be positive or negative about any paper but please be polite. If you are being critical you must mention at least one specific error, otherwise your comment will be deleted as unhelpful.

comments powered by Disqus